Individuals Must Stand Up Against Gender Bias in Medicine

Experts propose an ethical obligation for health professionals to intervene when they witness sexual harassment, gender bias.

5:00 PM

Author | Nicole Fawcett

Sexual harassment

As health care organizations move to create policies and training to eliminate gender bias and harassment, medical ethicists argue that it's not enough.

"Institutional efforts are absolutely essential. However, the sustained culture change that is necessary also requires individual commitment to action when gender bias or sexual harassment is observed," says Reshma Jagsi, M.D., D.Phil., director of the Center for Bioethics and Social Sciences in Medicine at the University of Michigan.

Jagsi and Michelle M. Mello, J.D., Ph.D., from Stanford University, co-authored a perspective published in the New England Journal of Medicine that outlines the ethical obligation of individuals to practice "upstanding," or intervening as bystanders, in response to sexual harassment or gender bias.

By framing gender bias as an ethical issue, individuals may feel more compelled to speak up, the authors say. This is especially important because many instances of bias or harassment may not rise to the level of an institutional investigation.

We simply cannot, as individual professionals, stand by without intervening when we observe this behavior.
Reshma Jagsi, M.D., D.Phil

The authors compare it to mandatory reporting when individuals witness a medical professional who appears physically impaired due to substance misuse. Jagsi notes several parallels, including that the offender may be in a more powerful position as well as the discomfort that people feel intervening.

"We have recognized the duty to protect patients from impaired physicians to be so strong that we expect one another to intervene, and we have accepted that we must do so if we observe such a situation," says Jagsi, Newman Family Professor and deputy chair of radiation oncology at Michigan Medicine.

SEE ALSO: Women in Medicine Say #MeToo, Report 'Appalling' Experiences

The authors note that many professional medical ethics codes address reporting impaired physicians but language around sexual harassment focuses on complying with institutional policies, with little to no expectation for responding to inappropriate behavior.

"In the case of sexual harassment or gender bias, observers may feel that the harm is somehow less profound than that which might be caused by an impaired physician," Jagsi says. "But the evidence is strong that sexual harassment and gender bias compromise the ability of our profession to care for patients optimally, not to mention the impact they have on our colleagues' own health."

MORE FROM THE LAB: Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

Jagsi and Mello note that upstanding is not always easy but that it can be learned. They offer suggested actions and language, ranging from pulling someone away from an inappropriate situation to calling out the perpetrator.

Regarding combating harassment and bias as a personal ethical obligation and not just an institutional responsibility, they say, will help achieve true culture change.

"Gender bias demonstrates a lack of respect for those within our profession, and can cause important consequences," Jagsi says. "We simply cannot, as individual professionals, stand by without intervening when we observe this behavior. Standing up is a matter of professional ethics and has to be recognized as such."

Paper cited: "Standing Up against Gender Bias and Harassment — A Matter of Professional Ethics," New England Journal of Medicine. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp1915351

Like Podcasts? Add the Michigan Medicine News Break to your Alexa-enabled device or subscribe for updates on iTunesGoogle Play and Stitcher.


More Articles About: Industry DX Gender Demographics
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe
Featured News & Stories Four gender-diverse people sitting in chairs at doctor’s office in vibrant color against a background of grey, each wearing the colors of a gender identity pride flag. From left to right, the gender identity flags represented are; transgender, nonbinary, genderqueer and gender fluid.
Health Lab
Putting gender inclusion into practice
Affirming a patient’s gender is something every health provider can do, even if gender medicine isn’t their specialty. Experts offer easy, actionable tips clinicians can use to make their practices more gender inclusive.
woman working from home in three different scenes being stressed out in colors blue grey and yellow
Health Lab
‘Seizing a disruptive opportunity’ to improve gender equity in medicine
Women have borne a disproportionate burden during the COVID-19 pandemic, and women in medicine are no exception. Can we seize this disruptive opportunity to improve gender equity in medicine?
women in window at home and man in lab
Health Lab
Is COVID-19 Widening the Gender Gap in Academic Medicine?
A new study finds fewer women publishing COVID-related papers, especially in early days of pandemic.
Photo of Reshma Jagsi
Health Lab
Michigan Medicine Celebrates Women in Medicine for International Women’s Day
Michigan Medicine Health Lab asked women at U-M how they're empowering the next generation of women for International Women's Day. These were their responses.
Conversation boxes on a yellow background
Health Lab
U-M Tackles #MedToo with Large-Scale Study on Sexual Harassment
A survey of Medical School faculty describes the impact of sexual harassment on physicians, helping leaders to outline paths to promote a culture of civility and respect.
Reshma Jagsi
Health Lab
To Diversify Leadership, Academic Medicine Should Implement Term Limits
To diversify leadership, researchers say term limits may create more opportunities for women and minorities in academic medicine.